1. Clearlytix
  2. Compare
  3. An SEO agency

Hiring an SEO agency vs Clearlytix

These aren’t alternatives. An SEO agency does the work: it writes the content, earns the links and fixes the pages. Clearlytix does none of that. It measures, diagnoses and recommends, so you know what needs doing before you pay for it and can see what changed afterwards.

This page compares a kind of service, not a company. Price ranges come from the published industry surveys listed at the foot of the page, read on 16 November 2026. Clearlytix doesn’t carry out or commission SEO work, and it doesn’t recommend a supplier.

At a glance

An SEO agency

Better suited to

  • Doing the work: content, links, technical fixes
  • Strategy and judgement about your market
  • Owning search as a channel, month after month
  • Businesses that know SEO is where their growth is

Clearlytix

Better suited to

  • Finding out what’s actually wrong before you spend
  • An independent record of what changed and when
  • Knowing whether the website is the problem at all
  • Checking on work you’re already paying for

Feature by feature

  • What it is An SEO agency: People who carry out SEO work for you. Clearlytix: An independent monthly report. It doesn’t carry out any work.
  • Finds problems An SEO agency: Yes, usually in an audit at the start and then as part of the retainer. Clearlytix: Yes, continuously. Checks run nightly and weekly and are written up every month.
  • Fixes problems An SEO agency: Yes. That’s what you’re paying for. Clearlytix: No. It says what to fix, who should do it, when, and how big a job it is.
  • Writes content and earns links An SEO agency: Yes. Clearlytix: No.
  • Judgement about your market An SEO agency: Yes. A good agency knows your industry, your customers and your competitors. Clearlytix: Limited to what the data shows: rankings, who appears for your customers’ searches, and what AI assistants say.
  • Reporting An SEO agency: Varies from agency to agency. Clearlytix: The same structure every month, with the source and a confidence level against each finding.
  • Checks whether work has been done An SEO agency: Reports on its own work. Clearlytix: Each report follows up the last: what was fixed, what still stands and how the numbers moved.
  • Says when nothing needs doing An SEO agency: Depends on the agency. Clearlytix: Yes. Separating website faults from outside causes is what it’s built for.
  • Cost An SEO agency: Recent surveys put most monthly retainers between $500 and $2,500. Clearlytix: $59 or $129 a month per website.

Clearlytix draws on more than a dozen sources: Google Analytics, Search Console, Cloudflare where the website runs through it, advertising and business-profile accounts, and its own uptime, speed, crawl, backlink, competitor and AI-answer checks. What Clearlytix needs for a complete report, with the access level for each connection.

What a report can diagnose alone

Clearlytix can tell you, without anyone’s help, whether the website is up, fast, indexed and free of broken links. It can show which pages are gaining and losing, where you rank and who outranks you, and whether AI assistants mention you. And it puts what’s worth doing in order.

It can’t do the doing. Rewriting a service page, earning a link from a trade body, restructuring a website, deciding which market to go after: those take a person, and often a specialist. Where a recommendation needs a developer or an SEO professional, the report says so.

Its value beside an agency is that it’s independent. It doesn’t carry out or commission any work, so it has no reason to find a problem that isn’t there. If the website is sound and the fall came from outside, that’s what it says.

Using a report with an agency

Before you hire. A report shows what’s actually wrong, so you can brief an agency on real problems and compare quotes against the same list.

While you work with one. The monthly follow-up shows which recommendations have been dealt with and how the numbers have moved. It isn’t proof that one change caused one result, and the report doesn’t pretend it is. It is an independent record.

If you don’t need one. Sometimes the answer is that the website is sound and the next step is small. That’s worth knowing before you sign a retainer.

Pricing and value

An SEO agency

Often $500 to $2,500 a month

  • SE Ranking and Duda, December 2024, 260 agencies: 64% charge under $1,000 a month.
  • Sitechecker, March 2026, 73 agencies: 42.5% charge under $1,000 and 26% charge $1,000 to $2,500.
  • Backlinko, 300+ SEO professionals: the average monthly cost is $1,000 to $2,500.
  • Surveys disagree, and the price depends on how much work is included.

Checked 16 November 2026. Current prices: seranking.com/blog/seo-pricing

Clearlytix

From $59 a month per website

  • Clearlytix Plus, $59 a month per website: the full monthly report.
  • Clearlytix Pro, $129 a month per website: adds what your advertising cost and what it brought back.
  • Agency pricing from $50 a month per website, on request.
  • Priced per website. No charge per user, per data source or per report.

Current prices: plans and pricing

The two prices buy different things, so the comparison only goes so far. An agency’s fee pays for hours of skilled work. Clearlytix pays for measurement and a written diagnosis. Spending $59 a month to make sure a much larger monthly fee is aimed at the right problem is the reason to have both.

Where an SEO agency is stronger

  • It does the work.Content, links and technical fixes get done, not just listed.
  • Judgement.Knowing which of ten possible actions suits your business takes experience a report doesn’t have.
  • Creativity.A campaign, an angle, a piece of content people want to link to.
  • Someone to hold to account.A named team responsible for the result.

Where Clearlytix is stronger

  • It’s independent.It doesn’t carry out the work it recommends.
  • It never stops checking.Uptime every five minutes, figures every night, a crawl every week.
  • It’s consistent.The same checks and the same structure every month, so months compare.
  • It tells you when to leave things alone.Fixing what isn’t broken wastes money, and the report says when that applies.
  • It costs little.A small fraction of a typical retainer.

Which should you choose?

Choose an SEO agency if

You know what needs doing and need people to do it, or you want someone to own search as a channel.

Choose Clearlytix if

You want to know what’s really going on before you spend, or you want an independent check on work you’re already paying for.

Most likely, both

A report to diagnose and keep score, and an agency or a developer to do the work. Clearlytix doesn’t replace SEO services and doesn’t try to.

Frequently asked questions

Can Clearlytix replace my SEO agency?

No. Clearlytix measures, diagnoses and recommends. It doesn’t write content, build links or change your website. If you need that work done, you need a person or an agency to do it.

Will Clearlytix fix the problems it finds?

No. Each recommendation says who should do it, when and how big a job it is. Whether to act, and who does the work, is your decision.

Why use Clearlytix if I already have an agency?

As an independent monthly record. It shows what changed on the website and in search, whether earlier recommendations have been dealt with, and how the numbers moved, written by something that doesn’t do the work.

Do I need an SEO agency at all?

It depends on what the report finds. If the website has faults or is losing ground in search, probably yes, or at least a developer. If it’s sound and the change came from outside, perhaps not yet.

Sources. Price ranges for SEO retainers come from the published surveys below, read on 16 November 2026. They measure different samples and don’t agree exactly.

See what a Clearlytix report says about your website.

  • Connect Google Analytics and Search Console once.
  • The report explains what changed, whether the website is the problem, and what to do next.

Clearer data. Clearer decisions. Better websites.